Good vs Bad Project Managers – What’s The Difference?

Project managers play a critical role in the success of any project. They are responsible for planning, organizing, and executing projects, ensuring that deliverables are achieved on time, within budget, and according to specifications. However, not all project managers are created equal. There is a clear distinction between good vs bad project managers, and understanding the difference can significantly impact the outcomes of a project.

In this article, we will explore the key differences between good and bad project managers and discuss the qualities that make a project manager successful.

The Good vs The Bad Project Managers

• Bad project managers will try to micromanage teams; good project managers will rely on their excellent leadership skills.
• Bad project managers are typically reactive, while good project managers are proactive when it comes to solving problems.
• Good project manager‘s consult data before making decisions, and bad project managers rely on rumors.
• Bad project managers blame complications on their team members, while good project managers take responsibility for their leadership.

Next, let’s take a deeper dive into understanding the difference between good project managers and bad ones.

What Makes a Good Project Manager?

If you have been in the workforce for a while, it is likely you have experience working with multiple project managers. Each of these individuals likely had different management styles! Some project managers offer great pieces of advice and mentorship. Others do not provide their team with the skills needed for success.

Good Project Managers are Leaders

Good project managers rely on their impeccable leadership skills to empower their teams to get the job done. They act as mentors and focus on highlighting people’s strengths over their weaknesses.

Bad project managers will simply tell their teams what to do without taking into consideration what these individuals are best at. While this methodology may seem minuscule, it can make a big difference in the overall success and happiness of the project team.

Good Project Managers are Proactive

Good project managers take advantage of a proactive approach when it comes to solving problems. They believe that it is important to plan thoroughly in order to solve problems before they start. Bad PMs do not take possible challenges into account, leaving their teams unprepared in times of trouble.

Qualities of a Good Project Manager

A good project manager possesses several essential qualities that set them apart from their counterparts:

• Strong Leadership: A good project manager is a strong leader who can inspire and motivate the project team. They provide clear direction, delegate tasks effectively, and foster a positive team culture.
• Excellent Communication: Effective communication is crucial for project success. Good project managers are skilled communicators who can articulate project goals, expectations, and progress to stakeholders at all levels.
• Organizational Skills: Good project managers excel in organizing project activities, resources, and timelines. They develop comprehensive project plans, monitor progress, and adapt as needed to keep the project on track.
• Problem-Solving Abilities: Challenges are inevitable in any project. Good project managers are adept at identifying and resolving issues promptly. They approach problems with a solution-oriented mindset and seek input from the project team.
• Adaptability: Project environments can be dynamic and unpredictable. Good project managers are flexible and can adapt to changing circumstances. They embrace new ideas and adjust project plans as necessary.
• Stakeholder Management: Successful project managers understand the importance of stakeholder management. They engage stakeholders, address concerns, and foster positive relationships to ensure project support and alignment.

Pitfalls of Bad Project Managers

On the other hand, bad project managers exhibit certain pitfalls that can lead to project failure:

• Poor Communication: Bad project managers struggle with effective communication, leading to misunderstandings, delays, and a lack of clarity among team members and stakeholders.
• Lack of Organization: Bad project managers fail to establish proper project plans, timelines, and resource allocation. This results in confusion, missed deadlines, and inefficient use of resources.
• Inadequate Leadership: Bad project managers lack leadership skills and struggle to motivate and guide their teams. This can lead to low team morale, decreased productivity, and a lack of team cohesion.
• Resistance to Change: Bad project managers resist change and are unwilling to adapt to new ideas or feedback. This hinders innovation and prevents the project from evolving in response to new challenges.
• Lack of Accountability: Bad project managers do not take responsibility for project outcomes and are quick to blame others for failures. This creates a negative work environment and erodes trust within the team.
• Poor Stakeholder Management: Bad project managers neglect to engage stakeholders, resulting in a lack of support and alignment. This can lead to conflicts, scope creep, and a loss of stakeholder confidence.

The Impact on Project Success

The difference between good and bad project managers has a direct impact on project success. A good project manager with strong leadership, effective communication, and organizational skills can drive the team towards achieving project goals, ensuring successful outcomes. They can navigate challenges, keep stakeholders engaged, and foster a productive work environment.

On the other hand, a bad project manager can derail a project, causing delays, budget overruns, and a dissatisfied team. Poor communication, lack of organization, and inadequate leadership can result in low team morale, increased conflicts, and a negative project culture. Stakeholders may lose confidence in the project, leading to decreased support and increased project risks.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the difference between good and bad project managers lies in their qualities and approach to project management. Good project managers possess strong leadership, communication, and organizational skills, while avoiding the pitfalls that make a bad project manager. Recognizing the qualities of a good project manager and avoiding the common pitfalls can significantly improve project outcomes and increase the chances of project success. Investing in developing project management skills and promoting a culture of effective project management can benefit organizations in achieving their project goals.

Have you led projects and are looking to earn a project management certification?  You might be interested in learning about how lucrative this can be.  Check out these articles.

Should You Become PMP Certified? – Here’s Why Becoming A Certified Project Management Professional Can Boost Your Career

13 PMP Benefits Once You Get The PMP Certification

No experience leading projects but still want to get into project management?  No problem!  Check out these articles.  

CAPM Certification Eligibility

What is a Certified Project Manager; How do I get PM Certifications