Cost-Benefit Analysis

What is Cost-Benefit Analysis?

Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is a decision-making tool used in project management to evaluate the financial and non-financial costs and benefits of a proposed action or investment. It involves comparing the total expected costs against the total expected benefits to determine whether the action will deliver a positive return or value. This analysis enables project managers and stakeholders to decide whether to proceed with a project, select between alternatives, or allocate resources effectively.

The process includes identifying and quantifying all relevant costs (such as labour, materials, and overhead) and benefits (like increased revenue, time savings, or improved service quality). These are often expressed in monetary terms to create an everyday basis for comparison. A successful analysis results in a net benefit, indicating that the project’s advantages outweigh its costs.

Key Points

• It supports evidence-based decision-making in project planning.
• It requires an accurate estimation of both direct and indirect costs and benefits.
• The results are often summarized using metrics such as net present value (NPV) or benefit-cost ratio (BCR).
• It helps prioritize projects based on their potential value to the organization.
• Non-financial factors, such as environmental impact or customer satisfaction, can also be considered where appropriate.

Related Terms

• A business case often includes a cost-benefit analysis to justify the project’s value.
• The project charter may reference the findings of a cost-benefit analysis to support the project’s approval.
• Risk management processes may use cost-benefit analysis to assess the value of proposed risk responses.
• A feasibility study includes cost-benefit analysis as a key component to determine project viability.
• Return on investment is a related performance measure that helps evaluate the profitability highlighted in a cost-benefit analysis.

Cost-Benefit Analysis: Example

A city plans to implement a new public transit system. The project team uses cost-benefit analysis to estimate total costs, including construction, maintenance, and staffing, which amount to $300 million. They then calculate the expected benefits, such as reduced traffic congestion, lower pollution, and economic growth, valued at $450 million over 10 years. Since the benefits exceed the costs, the city moves forward with the project.

Cost-Benefit Analysis: Best Practices

• Use consistent and realistic assumptions when estimating costs and benefits.
• Include both tangible and intangible factors to achieve a more comprehensive analysis.
• Document all data sources and assumptions to ensure transparency and facilitate future reference.
• Apply discounting methods to adjust for the time value of money when analyzing long-term projects.
• Review and update the analysis as new information becomes available throughout the project lifecycle.

Additional Resources

Preparing for a PMI certification?

• Exam Prep Courses: PMP^®, CAPM^®, and PMI-ACP^®
• Exam Simulators: PMP^®, CAPM^®, PMI-ACP^®, PMI-PBA^®, PMI-RMP^®, PMI-SP^®, PgMP^®, and PfMP^®
• Professional Development Units (PDUs): 15, 30, and 60 PDU Bundles