Confirmation Bias

June 17, 2025
« Back to Glossary Index

What is Confirmation Bias?

Confirmation bias is a psychological tendency where individuals favour information that confirms their existing beliefs or assumptions while ignoring or dismissing evidence that contradicts them. In project management, this bias can affect decision-making at every level, from initial planning to risk assessment and team evaluations. It often leads to selective data gathering, skewed interpretations, and resistance to alternative viewpoints, ultimately putting the project’s success at risk.

Project managers and team members may unknowingly fall into this bias when they seek validation for a chosen course of action, especially under time pressure or when emotionally invested in a particular outcome. Recognizing and addressing this tendency is crucial for maintaining objectivity and ensuring that project decisions are balanced and evidence-based.

Key Points

  • Confirmation bias can compromise the accuracy of project analysis and forecasts.
  • It may lead teams to ignore warning signs or emerging risks that contradict the project’s planned trajectory.
  • This bias often appears during stakeholder meetings, progress reviews, and performance assessments.
  • It can affect both individuals and group decision-making processes.
  • Awareness and deliberate checks against bias can improve overall project outcomes.

Related Terms

  • Cognitive bias includes confirmation bias and other mental shortcuts that can distort rational judgment in project contexts.
  • Risk management is especially vulnerable to confirmation bias when teams only acknowledge risks that support desired outcomes.
  • Stakeholder analysis can be compromised when confirmation bias leads teams to undervalue feedback from dissenting or less vocal stakeholders.
  • Decision-making frameworks help reduce the influence of confirmation bias by promoting structured and balanced approaches.
  • Project governance can counteract bias by ensuring transparent and diverse input in key decisions.

Confirmation Bias: Example

A project manager is convinced that a new software tool will improve team productivity. During the pilot phase, they focus only on positive feedback from enthusiastic users and overlook reports highlighting usability problems. As a result, the tool is fully implemented without adjustments, causing delays and frustration when broader team adoption proves difficult. This scenario illustrates how confirmation bias can lead to flawed conclusions and costly missteps.

Confirmation Bias: Best Practices

  • Encourage diverse perspectives and invite dissenting opinions during meetings to foster a more inclusive environment.
  • Use formal decision-making tools, such as SWOT analysis or decision matrices.
  • Implement peer reviews and third-party audits to challenge internal assumptions and ensure transparency and accountability.
  • Document all evidence, including contradictory data, during evaluations.
  • Train team members to recognize and question their assumptions.

Addressing confirmation bias actively strengthens project integrity and supports more informed, balanced decision-making.

Additional Resources

Confirmation Bias - Thinking, Fast and Slow     Confirmation Bias - Mistakes Were Made (but Not By Me) Third Edition: Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts

Preparing for a PMI certification?

« Back to Glossary Index